Addendum to material selection: JB Weld and JB KwikWeld.
A number of folks have done the repair successfully using JB Weld or JB KwikWeld and a fair question is why I didn't consider those. The reason was that I couldn't find specific data anywhere in their data sheets on Ethanol, and that was my primary focus for longevity of the repair. The only statement they do have is “When fully cured, J-B Weld is completely resistant to water, gasoline, and
about every other petroleum product or automotive chemical.” I even chased down some spirited -ha ha punny- discussions by distillers who were hesitant to use these in their distillation equipment for this reason.
Aspects to consider additionally may be: (1) these are both extremely strong and intended for permanent application and post machining, so once cured it may not be possible to access the solder points without drilling out should this be necessary in future. (2) JB Weld is less runny and would need care to ensure it has completely worked into the crevices around the wires, whereas KwikWeld comes with its mixer/applicator nozzle so may be easier to work with.
Related to this, there's an interesting video at
about JB WaterWeld (which is a putty in consistency so not best suited for this application). It shows email from the company saying that they have not tested for Ethanol and then shows a garage test in ethanol gas. I find this test a bit incomplete because (a) the temperature was near constant room/garage temp unlike the heat cycles from riding, (b) the amount of ethanol available to react in the gas was not being replenished as it would be during normal refills and may have run out or evaporated, (c) the original test is relatively short for 2 months but reports some reaction in a discussion later.
Based on not hearing any negative experiences from folks here, my impression is that JB Weld or KwikWeld and some other epoxies may be viable choices too. The bottom line is I don't think any of our epoxies will last “for ever” just some longer than others. What I would be very interested to see is any photos of the repairs several years afterward, to see how the different epoxies performed.
Peace!
PS. Not really topic of this discussion thread, but the whole Ethanol thing is a rabbit hole. I am now considering Caswell coating my plastic tank, and also machining a flange fitment (see
) as the O-ring fitment of the flange is becoming unreliable. Some are using -expensive- X-ring instead but I am leaning toward a more permanent solution. For now the flange fitment would be machined steel, as I can't yet 3D print the part from plastic which would need to be, wait...Ethanol resistant.