Thought I'd post a summary for anyone who doesn't get the magazine. They created a functional score (performance without regard to cost) and a total score (value factored in). They also rated individual features, but there isn't enough room to post those.
Fieldsheer Highland 2 (Best Buy)
Functional Score: 41.0
Total Score: 46.0
IXS Apollo (Recommended)
Functional Score: 43.0
Total Score: 45.0
Zero-60 Ambush (Recommended)
Functional Score: 39.5
Total Score: 44.5
Firstgear Kilamanjaro II (Recommended)
Functional Score: 41.5
Total Score: 44.5
Rukka A-Tech (Recommended)
Functional Score: 42.5
Total Score: 43.5
Aerostitch Darien (Recommended)
Functional Score: 40.5
Total Score: 42.0
Olympia Sentry (Recommended)
Functional Score: 38.5
Total Score: 41.5
Joe Rocket Ballistic 4.0
Functional Score: 34.0
Total Score: 38.0
Gericke Eco-Gore-Tex
Functional Score: 35.5
Total Score: 37.5
Hansa Atlanta
Functional Score: 24.0
Total Score: 29.0
Fieldsheer Highland 2 (Best Buy)
Functional Score: 41.0
Total Score: 46.0
IXS Apollo (Recommended)
Functional Score: 43.0
Total Score: 45.0
Zero-60 Ambush (Recommended)
Functional Score: 39.5
Total Score: 44.5
Firstgear Kilamanjaro II (Recommended)
Functional Score: 41.5
Total Score: 44.5
Rukka A-Tech (Recommended)
Functional Score: 42.5
Total Score: 43.5
Aerostitch Darien (Recommended)
Functional Score: 40.5
Total Score: 42.0
Olympia Sentry (Recommended)
Functional Score: 38.5
Total Score: 41.5
Joe Rocket Ballistic 4.0
Functional Score: 34.0
Total Score: 38.0
Gericke Eco-Gore-Tex
Functional Score: 35.5
Total Score: 37.5
Hansa Atlanta
Functional Score: 24.0
Total Score: 29.0