I think some people are just more rough on things than others. I've heard from friends I trust that FIELDSHEER is crap, btu I've had one of their jackets for over 2 years and it's 100% perfect..not even the slightest stich comming loose. Go figure. Someone may have already said this, but perhaps you can just e-mail/call someone at ICON and tell them you are disapointed in the quality. They should be MORE than willing to get you a new set of gloves at the LEAST. They are kind of new to the biz aren't they?