Ducati Monster Motorcycle Forum banner

Does a lighter flywheel increase or decrease rear wheel lock-up on downshifts?

2.7K views 10 replies 8 participants last post by  22080  
#1 ·
Logically, it seems to me that a lighter flywheel would decrease engine braking because you're decreasing the rotating inertial mass of the engine and thus it would take less force to bring the engine speed up or down to the equivelently geared road speed.  But I'm no engineer, so what do I know?  I've seen it posted that a lighter flywheel actually increases engine braking, but that doesn't make sense to me.

As for the term "engine braking," I'm referring for the most part to the rear tire's tendency to break away when down-shifting and not being careful enough with the clutch.

Could someone a little more enlightened explain it?
 
#2 ·
According to other threads on this topic, a light flywheel has been referred to as "the poor man's slipper clutch".

Sounds good to me!

Rideon
 
#6 ·
Imagine a a flywheel of stock mass being spun at a contant velocity, which means the bike is niether acceleration or decelerating.  At this condition the throttle needs to cracked open a little to maintain speed to over come driveline and aerodynamic drag.  When you accelerate the engine is applying torque in, what I'll call, the positive direction and the interia of the bike and the drivetrain has to respond to this input of power.  Heavier mass in the drivetrain will decrease it's responsiveness, because it takes more energy to get it to change rotating speeds.  Likewise lighter mass will increase the responsiveness of the drivetrain because it takes less energy to change rotating speeds.  So essentially it takes the same braking force from the engine to increase the resulting change in speed, because less rotating mass is applied the same braking force from the engine.
 
#9 ·
Much controversy here. I'm in the camp of increased engine braking with increased chance of rear wheel lock up. I don't think the flywheel effect overcomes the wheel with the quicker deceleration.
 
#10 ·
This controversy will apparently never be resolved!

It boils down to the difference between compression engine braking and inertial engine braking.
People typically use just the term engine braking and are most often referring to compression braking when they do so. Compression braking will cause rear wheel lockup.

The flywheel affecte inertial braking. Less inertia; less braking.

I'm in Howie's camp on this one. Sorry Norm ;D