After more than a dozen years, I recently switched from GEICO to SF, as they're the only insurer I could find who would provide coverage for home, bike, personal liability & 2 cars at competitive rates. Previously, I had the cars with GEICO, home with Allstate, and bike with Foremost. Even adding 1 mil in personal liability, the rates were lower (by a few hundred bucks) than what GEICO was offering without p.l. One of the agents I spoke with allowed that GEICO doesn't really like insuring bikes, but they do it to keep their primary business lines open. Mind your deductibles and limits of liability when making the decision as well; some companies will sound like they're welcoming you with open arms, but when you read the fine print, they're either severely limiting their exposure (by increasing yours) or requiring that youpay for coverage that you don't really need. No affiliation, but I went with Ginger L Gray, a SF agent in Fairfax. No claims yet (thankfully), but the customer service has been top notch.
Ginger L Gray
State Farm Insurance
www.statefarm.com